XTB vs Scalable Capital (2026):
Which Broker Is Right for German Investors?
Updated October 2026 · Written for investors resident in Germany
XTB S.A. charges 0% commission on real stocks and ETFs up to €100,000 of monthly turnover. Scalable Capital charges €1.99 per order on Xetra and gettex on both plans, and €0.99 on the European Investor Exchange, where PRIME+ trades from €250 and PRIME ETF purchases from €250 on either plan cost €0. On automated plans both execute ETF plans at €0, provided you fund XTB by bank transfer rather than recurring card top-ups at 0.70%. What decides it for a German investor is whether you buy manually or through a plan — and whether you want your tax withheld for you.
There are risks associated with investing.
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.
Who this comparison is written for
Both brokers behave differently by country. Pinning the comparison to one market is the only way to give you figures you can actually act on.
German clients are served by XTB S.A., the KNF-regulated Polish entity, through its German branch in Berlin, which is registered with BaFin and supervised in principle by the KNF. The branch publishes its own fee schedule containing a full stocks and ETFs section. That is what confirms real shares and ETFs are available here, and it is the entity every XTB figure on this page describes.
Scalable Capital Bank GmbH is a German bank in Munich, authorised by BaFin and supervised by BaFin and the Deutsche Bundesbank. Germany is its home market, and automatic withholding, the Freistellungsauftrag and the annual Jahressteuerbescheinigung are German-resident features.
Sources: XTB German branch Kosten- und Provisionsverzeichnis dated 29.06.2026 and the schedule valid from 30.09.2026; XTB S.A. commissions and fees table dated 29.06.2026; XTB Limited (Cyprus) table dated 02.04.2026; Scalable Capital Kundendokumente, Stand Juli 2026. Verified October 2026.
XTB vs Scalable Capital at a glance
Scalable Capital pricing reflects its fee page as read on 24 October 2026. XTB figures describe XTB S.A. as it serves German clients.
| Category | XTB (XTB S.A.) | Scalable Capital |
|---|---|---|
| Profile it suits | Investor buying manually, in EUR, who wants zero commission and a desktop trading platform | Set-and-forget saver, especially in Germany, who wants automated plans and tax handled |
| Entity serving Germany | XTB S.A., German branch (KNF, Poland) | Scalable Capital Bank GmbH (BaFin, German bank) |
| Commission, real ETFs | 0% up to €100,000/month | €1.99 on Xetra and gettex, both plans; €0.99 on the European Investor Exchange, €0 from €250 on PRIME+ and on PRIME ETF purchases |
| Monthly plan fee | €0 | €0 FREE / €4.99 PRIME+ |
| Automated plan execution | €0 | €0 per plan, from €1 |
| Plan minimum | €15 per plan | €1 |
| Currency conversion | 0.5%, and 0.5% twice on an indirect conversion | Markup exists, size not published |
| Fractional shares | Fractional Rights — a fiduciary right, not direct ownership; €1 minimum per stock or ETF | Not on manual orders; plans only |
| Cash interest | Paid automatically; higher rate for the first 90 days on the first €100,000; variable | Overnight account, variable rate on unlimited cash; broker cash 0% |
| Annual custody | Charged only on the excess above €250,000, at 0.02% p.a. | €0 |
| Auto tax handling (DE) | No — self-assessment; annual Erträgnisaufstellung supplied | Yes — Scalable Capital Bank GmbH |
| Inactivity fee | None in XTB’s German branch schedule | None stated in the fee schedule |
| CFDs | Yes — see the risk warning below | No CFD line in the fee schedule; derivatives priced separately |
Sources: Scalable Capital broker costs page, read 24 October 2026; XTB German branch schedule valid from 30.09.2026; XTB S.A. commissions and fees table 29.06.2026. Verified October 2026.
The real cost of each broker
Scalable prices manual orders by venue: one flat price on Xetra and gettex for both plans, and a lower price on the European Investor Exchange, with a PRIME+ discount from €250.
| Fee | XTB (XTB S.A.) | Scalable Capital |
|---|---|---|
| Commission, real stocks and ETFs | €0 up to €100,000 cumulative monthly turnover | €1.99 per trade on Xetra and gettex, FREE and PRIME+ alike; on the European Investor Exchange €0.99 per trade, or €0 from €250 on PRIME+ |
| PRIME ETF purchases from €250 | €0 up to €100,000 cumulative monthly turnover | €0 on the European Investor Exchange, both plans; €1.99 on Xetra and gettex |
| Above the threshold | 0.2%, minimum €10 | No turnover threshold |
| Automated plan execution | €0 — Investment Plans | €0 per plan from €1, both plans |
| Monthly plan fee | €0 | €0 FREE · €4.99 PRIME+, billed monthly in advance |
| Currency conversion | 0.5% on the XTB exchange rate; transfers between own cash accounts 0.5%, or 0.8% at weekends and on holidays | Undisclosed markup on the conversion rate |
| Annual custody | 0.02% p.a. on the excess above €250,000, charged monthly | €0 |
| Deposits | From 30 September 2026: card (PayU/Adyen) and bank transfer free; PayPal 0.85%; recurring savings-plan top-ups by PayU card 0.70%; first deposit free under the Free Start Deposit | €0 by transfer or direct debit; 0.99% / 0.69% via Instant on the first €5,000 |
| Withdrawals | Free from XTB; the client’s bank, card issuer or payment provider may charge | Not priced in the fee schedule |
| Transfer securities out | €25 per ISIN; Spanish listings 0.10% of value, minimum €100 | €0.00 plus any third-party costs |
| Inactivity | None in XTB’s German branch schedule | Not priced in the fee schedule |
On Xetra and gettex both plans pay €1.99 per trade, so PRIME+ saves nothing there. On the European Investor Exchange FREE pays €0.99 per trade and PRIME+ pays €0 from €250, so PRIME+ saves €0.99 on each trade of €250 or more in instruments other than PRIME ETFs. Purchases of PRIME ETFs (Amundi, iShares, Vanguard, Xtrackers) from €250 on the European Investor Exchange cost €0 on both plans, so they do not count toward any break-even.
QuantRoutine arithmetic, not a Scalable figure: €4.99 ÷ €0.99 = 5.04, so PRIME+ pays for itself on commission from the 6th qualifying trade on the European Investor Exchange in a month. Below that, or on Xetra and gettex, PRIME+ is a feature purchase — the reduced crypto spread, the cheaper Instant and Credit rates, the five-bank cash distribution and the platform extras.
Against XTB S.A. at 0% commission up to €100,000 of monthly turnover, no Scalable plan is cheaper on a manual order below that cap; Scalable can only match XTB at €0. Where Scalable competes is the savings plan leg, which executes at €0 per plan from €1 on both plans.
Sources: Scalable Capital broker costs page, read 24 October 2026, and List of Prices and Services, edition Stand Juli 2026, section E; XTB German branch schedule valid from 30.09.2026; XTB S.A. table 29.06.2026. Verified October 2026.
Four charges neither headline mentions
The headline is 0.5%. Where XTB quotes no direct rate between your account currency and the instrument currency, it converts first into USD and then into the target, applying 0.5% of the mid rate at each step. A two-leg conversion costs 0.5% twice. Holding an account in the currency you actually buy in avoids it entirely.
XTB clients’ shares sit on an omnibus account. The bank designated as withholding taxpayer does not know the identity or tax residence of XTB’s clients, so it cannot apply a double tax treaty and must use the highest rate local law allows. XTB names 30% for US listings, 35% for Czech and 35% for Portuguese.
Buying EUR-denominated UCITS ETFs on German venues avoids conversion on the trade itself. Foreign-currency turnover does not escape: Scalable’s contract converts at the prevailing rate plus a surcharge or minus a discount, and the conversion may be performed by Scalable or by an intermediate custodian. The size is published nowhere. Treat any zero-FX claim about Scalable as wrong.
Savings plans execute at €0 with one exception. Crypto ETPs carry a spread surcharge of 0.99% on FREE and 0.69% on PRIME+ on every execution, plan executions included, and it applies to every instrument tracking a cryptocurrency, ETPs, ETCs and ETNs alike. Funds carry their own surcharge of up to 5% on every leg under the contract, against a €0 front-end load on the fee page — an unresolved contradiction, so treat Scalable funds as not established to be free.
Investment Plans vs savings plans
Both execute ETF plans at €0. What differs is what they can hold, how finely you can schedule them, and how you fund them.
| Plan feature | XTB Investment Plans | Scalable Capital savings plans |
|---|---|---|
| Execution cost | €0, within the €100,000 monthly cap | €0 per plan, both plans |
| Minimum | €15 per plan | €1 |
| What it can hold | ETFs and stocks, including US stocks; stock savings plans in Germany since 10 July 2026 | ETFs, shares, crypto ETPs and funds |
| Intervals | Recurring; XTB states the rhythm is the client’s choice | Five intervals, nine selectable days of the month |
| Concurrent plans | Up to 10, each with up to 20 instruments | One plan per security |
| Funding | Account balance, or Auto-invest recurring top-ups; recurring top-ups by PayU card cost 0.70%, while bank transfers into the account are free | Cash balance or SEPA direct debit, €0 |
| Management or custody fee on the plan | None | None |
- A new plan or a change to one needs five banking days before the next execution date to take effect
- Amounts are allocated to six decimal places and rounded down, so a small residue of each contribution stays as cash
- Scalable reserves the rate from your cash balance first and falls back to a direct debit from the reference account; reserved cash is not spendable
- A returned direct debit locks the plan until the payment method is corrected in the plan summary
- Execution timing depends on tradability and available balance, and Scalable states in the contract that it cannot be guaranteed
- Where a plan can execute on only one venue, your order is contractually deemed to include an instruction to use that venue — and a client venue instruction is precisely the condition under which the best-execution duty is discharged by following it
Sources: Scalable Capital ETF savings plan page and help centre, read 30 August 2026; Scalable Special Terms and Conditions Broker clause 7.4 with Execution Policy clause 7; XTB Investment Plans help centre article updated 11 August 2026 and XTB Germany savings plan announcement of 10 July 2026; XTB German branch schedule valid from 30.09.2026. Verified October 2026.
Fractional shares and uninvested money
XTB Fractional Rights are not direct ownership: XTB’s UK documents describe them as a fiduciary right to a fraction of a share that XTB buys whole. Under XTB’s UK Terms of Business they cannot be traded or transferred to anyone else and cannot be moved to another account, which blocks an in-specie transfer out. XTB Poland states that the KDPW investor compensation scheme does not cover them, and exercising voting rights on them is a charged service at €50.
Scalable fractionals cannot be bought directly at all. They arise only inside savings plans, are periodically consolidated back into whole units, and route to the European Investor Exchange. A position containing fractions can be sold, but an individual fraction cannot — the entire position has to go.
Scalable pays 2.60% p.a.* (variable, read 24 October 2026) on unlimited cash in the Overnight account, on both plans, calculated daily and paid monthly. It is a separate account with its own IBAN and real-time internal transfers, and it only pays if you actively deposit into it. Cash sitting in the broker clearing account earns 0%.
*2.60% interest p.a. on unlimited Overnight savings, clearing accounts as per interest overview. Interest variable, for instance based on market rates. With PRIME+, up to 5 x €100,000 statutory deposit guarantee by allocating across up to 5 banks. Without PRIME+, allocation across banks with statutory deposit guarantee or money market funds where European investor protection rules (UCITS) apply, each possible as sole safekeeping method. Fixed-term savings with guaranteed interest on unlimited cash allocated across one or more banks with €100,000 statutory deposit guarantee. Additional contractual deposit guarantee possible. Allocations are variable, for instance based on capacities and conditions.
XTB pays on free funds automatically, accruing daily and credited within five working days of month end, with no minimum balance. In Germany a higher rate applies for the first 90 days after opening, on the first €100,000 across all accounts — 3.50% on EUR when read on 23 September 2026 — and the standard rate applies after that and above €100,000. XTB can change its rates weekly, so read the current standard rate on XTB’s German interest page before you rely on it.
Regulation, protection and who files your tax return
Protection schemes cover different things at each broker. They are not a like-for-like number, and any page presenting them as one is telling you something false.
| Feature | XTB | Scalable Capital |
|---|---|---|
| Entity you contract with | XTB S.A., Warsaw, acting through its German branch | Scalable Capital Bank GmbH, Munich |
| Supervision | KNF (Poland) as home regulator; German branch registered with BaFin | Authorised by BaFin; supervised by BaFin and the Deutsche Bundesbank |
| Cash protection | XTB states German clients’ cash is held on segregated trust accounts at partner banks, currently including J.P. Morgan SE, under the German €100,000 statutory deposit guarantee | €100,000 statutory per bank; on PRIME+, Overnight balances across up to 5 banks for up to 5 × €100,000 |
| Securities custody | Omnibus account with XTB’s partner custodian; client assets segregated from XTB’s own. KDPW investor compensation up to €20,100, excluding Fractional Rights | Collective safe custody at Clearstream with client co-ownership; foreign holdings by credit in securities account |
| Custody fee | 0.02% p.a. on the excess above €250,000 | €0 |
| Ownership | XTB S.A. is listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange | BlackRock, Inc. is an indirect minority shareholder of the parent company |
| Withholding, Germany | No — self-assessment; XTB supplies an annual Erträgnisaufstellung | 25% plus 5.5% solidarity surcharge, and church tax where applicable; Freistellungsauftrag applied, €1,000 individual / €2,000 joint |
| Outside Germany | Country-specific — for example, a year-end portfolio statement for Spain’s Modelo 720, and possible withholding on interest in Portugal | No withholding; Scalable states it may commission a tax report at no charge, with no warranty as to content |
Sources: Scalable Capital Kundendokumente, Stand Juli 2026, sections C.IV and E; XTB German website account and fees and interest pages, read 23.09.2026; XTB Poland client funds protection page; XTB German branch schedule valid from 30.09.2026. Verified October 2026.
Pros, cons, and who each broker actually fits
- 0% commission on real stocks and ETFs up to €100,000 of turnover a month, with no subscription
- Investment Plans free to run, with no management or custody fee, holding ETFs and stocks, up to ten at once
- Interest paid on uninvested cash automatically, with a higher rate for the first 90 days on the first €100,000
- No inactivity fee in XTB’s German branch schedule
- No custody fee below €250,000, and 0.02% a year above it is low
- xStation runs on desktop, tablet and mobile
- XTB S.A. is publicly listed, so its financials are in the open
- No German tax withholding — you declare it yourself, using XTB’s annual Erträgnisaufstellung
- 30% withheld on US dividends through omnibus custody, with no treaty relief
- 0.5% currency conversion, charged twice on an indirect conversion
- Under XTB’s UK terms, Fractional Rights cannot be transferred out, and KDPW compensation does not cover them
- Recurring savings-plan top-ups by PayU card cost 0.70%
- €25 per ISIN to move holdings to another broker
- Savings plans from €1 at €0 per execution, on both plans
- Plan engine with five intervals, nine days, four asset classes, SEPA direct debit and an inflation uplift
- Automatic German tax withholding and an annual certificate
- Interest on unlimited cash in the Overnight account, on both plans (variable; rate and Scalable’s disclaimer in the cash section)
- No custody fee and €0 to transfer securities out
- One legal entity, Scalable Capital Bank GmbH, serving six countries
- Manual orders cost €1.99 on Xetra and gettex and €0.99 on the European Investor Exchange, against 0% at XTB below €100,000 a month; €0 applies only from €250 on the European Investor Exchange, on PRIME+ or for PRIME ETF purchases
- PRIME+ at €4.99 a month pays for itself on commission only from the 6th qualifying trade on the European Investor Exchange in a month (QuantRoutine arithmetic)
- No fractional shares on manual orders, and plan fractions cannot be sold on their own
- Interest requires actively funding a separate account; broker cash pays 0%
- A currency conversion markup exists and its size is published nowhere
- Crypto ETP plan executions carry a 0.99% or 0.69% spread surcharge
- No published customer service telephone number
- You place manual orders as well as plan contributions, where the 0% commission is decisive
- You hold your account in the currency you actually buy in, so the 0.5% never bites
- You are comfortable declaring investment income yourself rather than having it withheld
- Your portfolio sits below €250,000, where XTB’s custody fee is zero
- You want a desktop trading platform alongside a passive strategy
- Essentially all of your buying happens through automated plans
- You want the Freistellungsauftrag, withholding and the annual certificate handled for you
- You want scheduling control: interval, day of month, inflation uplift, direct debit
- You want to contribute round amounts from €1 rather than whole units
- You hold meaningful cash and will actually move it into the Overnight account
On manual orders below €100,000 of monthly turnover, XTB S.A. is never more expensive on commission: 0% against €1.99 on Xetra and gettex and €0.99 on the European Investor Exchange at Scalable. Scalable matches XTB at €0 only on trades from €250 on the European Investor Exchange, on PRIME+ at €4.99 a month or for PRIME ETF purchases on either plan.
If you buy only through plans, the cost argument largely disappears — both execute ETF plans at €0, as long as you fund XTB by bank transfer rather than recurring card top-ups at 0.70% — and the decision moves to the plan engine and the tax handling, where only Scalable withholds German tax. A German investor contributing monthly and never placing a manual order is choosing on scheduling and on withholding, not on price.
For a German investor this is a decision about how you buy and how you want tax handled: withholding, the Freistellungsauftrag and plans on nine days of the month, or zero commission and a desktop trading platform with the tax declaration left to you.
Ready to open an account?
Check both brokers on their official sites before deciding. For a German investor the pick comes down to whether you buy manually or through a plan, whether you want withholding handled for you, and how much scheduling control you want over your contributions.
The statements, comments and other content contained in this article, even if individual issuers or financial instruments are mentioned, are not to be construed as investment advice and do not constitute, directly or indirectly, a recommendation or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any financial instrument or any advice relating thereto. There are risks associated with investing.
Common questions
Is XTB or Scalable Capital cheaper for EU ETF investing?
It depends on whether you buy manually or through a plan, and on the venue. On manual orders XTB charges 0% commission up to €100,000 of cumulative monthly turnover. Scalable Capital charges €1.99 per order on Xetra and gettex on both plans. On the European Investor Exchange it charges €0.99 per order, €0 on PRIME+ for trades from €250, and €0 on both plans for purchases of PRIME ETFs from €250. On automated plans both brokers execute ETF plans at €0, provided you fund XTB by bank transfer, because XTB charges 0.70% on recurring savings-plan top-ups by PayU card. Every XTB figure here describes XTB S.A., which serves German clients through its German branch.
Which XTB entity will I get, and why does it matter?
XTB is not one broker. XTB S.A. is regulated by the KNF in Poland and offers real stocks, ETFs, Fractional Rights and Investment Plans. XTB Limited (Cyprus) is regulated by CySEC and offers none of them, only CFDs, options and spot crypto. XTB S.A. serves Germany, Poland, France, Spain, Portugal and Romania through its own entity and branches. Dutch residents are served by XTB Limited (Cyprus), and XTB support confirmed in September 2026 that real stocks and ETFs are not available to them. In any other country, check which entity your account agreement names before you deposit. Every 0% commission figure on this page describes XTB S.A. only.
Does Scalable Capital automatically handle German taxes?
Yes, for clients taxable in Germany. Scalable Capital Bank GmbH applies the Freistellungsauftrag, capped at €1,000 for an individual and €2,000 jointly, withholds 25% Kapitalertragsteuer plus the 5.5% solidarity surcharge and church tax where applicable, and issues an annual Jahressteuerbescheinigung, normally by the end of April. Outside Germany, Scalable states that it may commission a report of tax-relevant income at no additional charge, but it does not withhold and gives no warranty as to content. XTB does not withhold German tax: German clients declare the income themselves, and XTB supplies an annual Erträgnisaufstellung.
Can I buy fractional shares at both XTB and Scalable Capital?
Both offer fractional exposure and both restrict it, in different ways. XTB Fractional Rights are a fiduciary right to a fraction of a share rather than direct ownership. Under XTB’s UK Terms of Business they cannot be traded or transferred to anyone else and cannot be moved to another account, which blocks any in-specie transfer out, and XTB Poland states that the KDPW compensation scheme does not cover them. Scalable Capital does not offer fractional shares on manual orders at all. Fractional positions arise only inside savings plans from €1, they route to the European Investor Exchange, and an individual fraction cannot be sold on its own. The whole position must be liquidated to exit.
How does cash interest compare between XTB and Scalable Capital?
Scalable Capital pays interest on its Overnight account at a variable rate, on unlimited cash, on both plans, calculated daily and paid monthly; the current rate and Scalable’s interest disclaimer are in the cash section above. Cash left in the broker clearing account earns 0%, so the money has to be actively moved into the Overnight account to earn anything. XTB pays interest automatically on uninvested funds with no minimum balance. In Germany a higher rate applies for the first 90 days after opening on the first €100,000, and the standard rate applies after that and above €100,000. XTB can change its rates weekly and publishes the current German rates at xtb.com/de/zinsen. Both rates are variable.
Which broker has better savings plan options?
Scalable Capital, on flexibility. Savings plans start at €1, execute at €0 on both plans, run across five intervals on nine selectable days of the month, cover ETFs, shares, crypto ETPs and funds, and carry an optional inflation uplift of 2, 3, 5 or 8% applied pro rata after each execution. XTB Investment Plans are also free to run with no management or custody fee. Up to ten can run at once, each holding up to 20 ETFs and stocks, they can be created in the mobile app or on the web platform, and the minimum is €15 per plan.
Is my money safe with XTB or Scalable Capital?
Both are regulated in the EEA and both segregate client assets, but the protections cover different things and are not directly comparable. Scalable Capital Bank GmbH is authorised by BaFin and supervised by BaFin and the Deutsche Bundesbank. Cash carries the German statutory deposit guarantee of €100,000 per bank; on PRIME+, Overnight account balances are distributed across Scalable and four partner banks for up to 5 × €100,000, though a balance may also sit entirely with one bank or one money market fund. Securities are held in collective safe custody at Clearstream, where the client acquires co-ownership, which is a different mechanism from deposit insurance. XTB S.A. is regulated by the KNF in Poland and is listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange. XTB states that German clients’ cash is held on segregated trust accounts at partner banks under the German €100,000 deposit guarantee, and the Polish KDPW investor compensation scheme covers up to €20,100 per investor, excluding Fractional Rights.
Get the free toolkit sample
A working broker cost calculator — IBKR vs DEGIRO vs Trading 212, with verified fees. You’ll also get 4 short emails on cutting your investing costs. Unsubscribe anytime.
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.