Broker Comparison
XTB vs Trade Republic (2026):
Which Is Better for UCITS ETF Investors?
Updated September 2026 · By Francesco Cipolli · How we verify fees
Neither broker charges custody on a portfolio under €250,000, and neither charges per savings-plan execution. But they are built for different investors. XTB gives you commission-free manual trades up to €100,000 a month, a platform across mobile, desktop and tablet, and CFDs alongside real ETFs. Trade Republic gives you one app for investing, a payment card and interest on cash, with savings plans from €10, and it is itself a licensed German bank. The right choice depends on how you invest, not just what you pay.
![]()
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.
Who each broker is built for
Both brokers serve EU UCITS ETF investors well, but they optimise for different behaviour. If you have any doubt, the column that applies to you is the one that matches how you actually invest week to week.
Better if you…
- Place manual ETF and stock trades: 0% commission up to €100,000 of turnover per calendar month
- Want a platform on desktop and tablet as well as the app
- Want CFDs available alongside real stocks and ETFs
- Want several ETFs and stocks automated in one plan, at weightings you set
- Prefer a broker listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange that publishes quarterly results
Better if you…
- Run a recurring savings plan and rarely trade manually: no cost per plan execution
- Want to start small: savings plans from €10 per execution, one-off fractional buys from €1
- Want investing, a payment card and interest on cash in one app
- Spend abroad: €0 currency conversion fee on card payments and foreign-currency ATM withdrawals
- Want a broker that is itself a licensed German bank, supervised by BaFin
Fee comparison: XTB vs Trade Republic
Figures from each broker’s published fee schedule. Fees can change, so confirm on the broker’s official pricing page before opening an account.
| Fee | XTB | Trade Republic |
|---|---|---|
| Manual ETF or stock trade | 0% commission up to €100,000 of turnover per calendar month (buys and sells); 0.2% above that, min. €10 | €0 commission plus a €1 settlement flat rate per trade, charged once per trading day on partial fills |
| Savings plan execution | 0% commission; plan purchases count toward the €100,000 monthly threshold | €0 per execution; the €1 settlement flat rate does not apply |
| Savings plan size | From €15 per plan | €10 to €10,000 per execution |
| Currency conversion | 0.5% on every trade that needs a conversion; where there is no direct pair, XTB converts via USD and applies 0.5% at each step | Foreign dividends and corporate-action income are converted at the interbank rate plus a fixed margin per currency unit (USD 0.0014, GBP 0.0011) |
| Custody | 0.02% p.a. on the part of average daily portfolio value above €250,000; nothing below | Free |
| Fractional one-off buys | From €1 (Germany, Portugal) | From €1 |
| Outgoing transfer per position | €25 per ISIN (Spain-listed: 0.10%, min. €100) | Free; third-party costs may apply |
| Inactivity fee | €10/month only after 365 days with no trade AND no deposit in the prior 90 days; not charged while you hold an open position; XTB’s German branch schedule charges none | No inactivity fee line in Trade Republic’s price list |
Source: XTB — XTB S.A. fees and commissions table of 29 June 2026, read August 2026, and XTB’s German branch schedule valid from 30 September 2026, read September 2026.
Source: Trade Republic — Preis- und Leistungsverzeichnis v11.2025 and Trade Republic’s currency conversion page, verified August 2026. For EUR-listed UCITS ETFs bought with euros, no currency conversion is involved at either broker.
Break-even math
One manual ETF buy a month costs €12 a year in settlement fees at Trade Republic and €0 at XTB while you stay under €100,000 of monthly turnover. Savings-plan-only investors pay nothing per execution at either. Two costs to watch: Trade Republic charges 1% on every instant card or wallet top-up after the first (bank transfers in are free), and XTB’s inactivity fee applies only after 365 days with no trade and no deposit in the prior 90 days, is not charged while you hold an open position, and does not appear in XTB’s German branch schedule at all.
Savings plans and UCITS ETF access
XTB — Investment Plans
- Up to 10 plans per account, each holding up to 20 instruments weighted 5% to 100%
- Plans can hold ETFs and stocks, including US stocks
- Minimum €15 per plan
- Auto-invest: recurring top-ups where you choose the amount, the period and the deposit method
- Set up in the mobile app or on the web platform
- 0% commission within the €100,000 monthly threshold; plan purchases count toward it
- Components may execute at different times of day, depending on exchange hours
- Germany: recurring plan top-ups by card via PayU cost 0.70% on EUR from 30 September 2026
Trade Republic — Savings Plans
- Savings plans on ETFs, stocks, ELTIFs and crypto
- €0 per execution; the €1 settlement flat rate does not apply
- €10 to €10,000 per execution
- One-off fractional buys from €1, separate from savings plans
- Where several customers buy the same instrument on the same date across partial fills, Trade Republic settles all of them at one average price
- Rounding to the fourth decimal place can make an executed instalment slightly smaller than the amount you set
- Manual trades: €0 commission plus the €1 settlement flat rate
XTB’s Investment Plans suit a multi-fund portfolio automated as one instruction: up to 20 ETFs and stocks at the weightings you set. Trade Republic’s entry point is lower (€10 per execution against €15 per XTB plan), and each execution is capped at €10,000. For a single ETF bought monthly, either platform handles the job cleanly.
Platform and everyday use
The two take different approaches. XTB is a trading platform available across devices. Trade Republic is an investing app that also handles payments and cash.
xStation
XTB’s xStation platform runs on mobile, desktop and tablet, with an economic calendar and XTB’s educational courses. Investment Plans can be set up in the app or on the web platform, and a demo account is available. Support is by email, chat or phone, Monday to Friday, in 18 languages. In the ForexBrokers.com 2026 Annual Awards, XTB finished Best in Class for Overall, Ease of Use and Beginners.
Economic calendar
CFD access
Demo account
App and card
Trade Republic combines a securities account and a cash account with a payment card. The virtual card is free; a physical Classic card costs €5 one-off. Card payments and ATM withdrawals in foreign currency carry no conversion fee, and ATM withdrawals cost €1 under €100 and nothing from €100. Incoming bank transfers, standing orders and direct debits are free. Trade Republic’s German site advertised 1% Saveback on card spending in August 2026.
Debit card
€0 card FX
Saveback
Interest on uninvested cash
XTB
XTB pays interest on uninvested cash. The rate is variable and can change weekly; interest accrues daily and is paid within five working days of month end, with no minimum balance. Rates and structure differ by country: in Germany, a preferential rate applies for the first 90 days after account opening on the first €100,000 across all accounts, after which the standard rate applies. Check the rate for your country before depositing a large balance.
Trade Republic
Interest must be activated in the app; it is not automatic. Balances blocked by open orders or pending card settlements earn nothing. Cash above a threshold Trade Republic sets in the app, the Partner Amount, is invested in qualified money market funds held in Trade Republic’s name for your account. Any rate above the base rate comes from a top-up Program with eligibility criteria, which Trade Republic may end on two weeks’ notice.
Key difference: XTB’s rate is a variable rate it can reset weekly, and in Germany it starts with a 90-day preferential rate. Trade Republic’s rate depends on activation and can include a terminable top-up, and part of a larger balance may sit in a money market fund rather than a bank account. Compare the live rates on each broker’s page on the day you deposit.
Regulation and investor protection
XTB is an investment firm; Trade Republic is a bank. That changes how cash and securities are held and which protection applies.
XTB
- Entity: XTB S.A., a Polish investment firm authorised by the KNF, serving clients in Poland directly and through branches in Germany (registered with BaFin), France (AMF and ACPR), Spain (CNMV no. 40) and Portugal (CMVM no. 341); Romanian clients are served under its KNF authorisation, with ASF registration
- Netherlands: Dutch residents are served by XTB Limited (Cyprus, CySEC licence 169/12), which offers CFDs only, with no real stocks or ETFs
- Investor compensation (XTB S.A.): KDPW scheme, 100% up to €3,000 and 90% above that up to €22,000, a maximum of €20,100 per investor; Fractional Rights are not covered
- Investor compensation (Cyprus entity): Investor Compensation Fund, up to €20,000 per covered client
- Cash, Germany: XTB states clearing-account cash sits in segregated trust accounts at partner banks, covered by the German deposit guarantee up to €100,000 in a partner-bank failure
- Segregation: client money is kept separate from XTB’s own funds; holdings sit on an omnibus account with XTB’s partner custodian
- Publicly listed: Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016
Trade Republic
- Entity: Trade Republic Bank GmbH, Berlin, a licensed CRR credit institution supervised by BaFin
- Spain: a Madrid branch supervised by the Banco de España and the CNMV
- Cash: held in omnibus trust accounts; amounts above the Partner Amount are invested in qualified money market funds, which are fund units, not bank deposits
- Protection: Trade Republic states that it and its trust banks belong to a statutory compensation scheme in the EU; its price list and customer agreement state no limit
- Inducements: Trade Republic may receive payments from third parties for executing orders and keep them; they are disclosed to clients annually
Bottom line on protection: neither broker gives you one number that covers everything. XTB publishes investor compensation up to €20,100 per investor under KDPW, and for German clients states that cash is covered by the German deposit guarantee up to €100,000. Trade Republic is a bank, but part of a larger cash balance can sit in money market funds rather than deposits, and its documents state no protection limit. Compensation schemes cover broker failure, not investment losses.
Account types and where each broker operates
XTB
- Standard retail account
- Demo account available
- Options available through XTB’s German branch
- France: PEA for French tax residents
- Real stocks and ETFs via XTB S.A. in Poland, Germany, France, Spain, Portugal and Romania
- Netherlands: XTB Limited (Cyprus), CFDs only
Trade Republic
- One account combining securities, cash and a payment card
- Savings plans, one-off trades and crypto; crypto custody is free and transfers out are free plus network fees
- Germany: annual tax certificate free of charge
- Spain: customers who migrate to the Madrid branch get a Spanish IBAN and fall under Spanish IRPF withholding and reporting
- The account is tied to one country: Trade Republic’s Portuguese-market customer agreement lists moving country, including to another country Trade Republic serves, as grounds for termination without notice
Ready to open an account?
If you trade manually and want a platform across devices with CFDs alongside real ETFs, XTB is the stronger fit. If you run a set-and-forget savings plan and want investing, a payment card and cash interest in one app from a licensed German bank, Trade Republic is built for that workflow.
Go deeper
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for UCITS ETF investing, XTB or Trade Republic?
For savings plans, neither charges per execution: XTB’s Investment Plans are commission-free within its €100,000 monthly threshold, and Trade Republic’s savings plans cost nothing per execution. For manual trades, XTB charges 0% commission up to €100,000 of monthly turnover, while Trade Republic charges no commission but a €1 settlement flat rate per trade. One manual trade a month costs €12 a year at Trade Republic and €0 at XTB. XTB suits investors who trade manually or want several ETFs and stocks in one plan; Trade Republic suits savings-plan investors who want investing, a payment card and cash interest in one app.
Does XTB charge commission on ETF trades?
No. XTB charges 0% commission on real stock and ETF trades up to €100,000 of cumulative turnover in a calendar month, counting buys and sells across all your accounts. Trades after that threshold cost 0.2%, with a €10 minimum. A 0.5% fee applies when a trade needs a currency conversion.
Is Trade Republic a bank?
Yes. Trade Republic Bank GmbH, based in Berlin, is a licensed CRR credit institution supervised by BaFin. It runs a cash account with a payment card alongside the securities account. Cash above a threshold Trade Republic sets in the app, the Partner Amount, is invested in qualified money market funds rather than held as a bank deposit.
Can I buy fractional ETFs on both XTB and Trade Republic?
Yes. XTB’s minimum per stock or ETF is €1 in Germany and Portugal. Trade Republic allows one-off fractional buys from €1. At XTB, fractions are held as Fractional Rights, which XTB Poland states are not covered by the KDPW investor compensation scheme.
What is the minimum savings plan at XTB and Trade Republic?
XTB Investment Plans start at €15 per plan and can hold up to 20 ETFs and stocks at weightings you set. Trade Republic savings plans run from €10 to €10,000 per execution and cover ETFs, stocks, ELTIFs and crypto. Neither broker charges per plan execution.
Which broker has better investor protection?
They are structured differently. XTB S.A. clients are covered by the Polish KDPW scheme: 100% up to €3,000 and 90% above that up to €22,000, a maximum of €20,100 per investor, excluding Fractional Rights. For German clients, XTB states that cash sits in trust accounts at partner banks covered by the German deposit guarantee up to €100,000. Trade Republic is a bank and states that it and its trust banks belong to a statutory EU compensation scheme, but its price list and customer agreement give no limit, and cash above its Partner Amount is held in money market funds. Compensation schemes cover broker failure, not investment losses.
Get the free toolkit sample
A working broker cost calculator — IBKR vs DEGIRO vs Trading 212, with verified September 2026 fees. You’ll also get 4 short emails on cutting your investing costs. Unsubscribe anytime.
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.