XTB vs Trading 212 (2026):
Fees, FX and Automation Compared
Both brokers charge no commission on ETFs within their own rules. The cost gap is currency conversion: 0.5% at XTB against 0.15% at Trading 212. Everything else is structural: XTB’s monthly commission cap and inactivity rule, Trading 212’s Pies, which legal entity serves your country, and what each compensation scheme actually covers.
![]()
The short answer
Choose Trading 212 if…
- You buy ETFs or stocks priced in another currency (0.15% FX vs 0.5%)
- You want Pies of up to 50 holdings, or recurring buys into a single instrument
- You live in the Netherlands and want real ETFs, not CFDs
- You want interest on uninvested cash paid daily (opt-in)
- You want a price list with no inactivity fee row
Choose XTB if…
- You only buy EUR-priced ETFs from a EUR account, so the FX gap never applies
- You want options: XTB offers them in the UK, Cyprus and Germany
- You want a CFD-led broker: CFDs are the core of XTB’s business
- You want a broker listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange that reports quarterly
- You are in France and want a PEA
XTB vs Trading 212 at a glance
| Feature | XTB | Trading 212 |
|---|---|---|
| Commission, stocks and ETFs | 0% up to €100,000 monthly turnover, then 0.2% (min €10) | €0, no turnover threshold |
| Currency conversion | 0.5% (0.5% per step when converted via USD) | 0.15%, including weekends |
| Custody fee | 0.02% p.a. on portfolio value above €250,000 | €0 |
| Inactivity fee | €10/month (£10 per XTB UK’s site) after 365 days without a trade and 90 days without a deposit; waived with any open position; none in XTB’s German branch schedule | No inactivity fee row on the price list |
| Minimum deposit | £0 (UK); €1 (Germany, Portugal) | €1 (EU, Cyprus entities); £1 (UK) |
| Minimum per stock or ETF order | £1 (UK); €1 (Germany, Portugal); €10 (French PEA) | €1 (EU, Cyprus entities); £1 (UK) |
| Recurring investing | Investment Plans: up to 10 plans, 20 ETFs or stocks each, min €15 | Pies (up to 50 holdings) and single-instrument AutoInvest |
| Interest on uninvested cash | Accrued daily, paid monthly; rate set per entity | Opt-in, paid daily; rate set per entity |
| Portfolio transfer out | €25 per ISIN (Spain-listed: 0.10%, min €100) | No Trading 212 fee; whole shares only |
| Investor compensation (EU) | KDPW, max €20,100 (XTB S.A.) | EdW, 90% of value up to €20,000 (Trading 212 EU); ICF up to €20,000 (Trading 212 Markets) |
| Netherlands residents | XTB Limited (Cyprus): CFDs only, no real stocks or ETFs | Trading 212 EU GmbH: real stocks and ETFs |
| CFD account | Yes | Yes |
Source: XTB — XTB S.A. fee table of 29.06.2026, German branch schedule valid from 30.09.2026, XTB Limited (UK) fee table of 14.03.2026 and XTB’s own country sites, verified September 2026.
Source: Trading 212 — published Terms & Fees (UK, NL and Cyprus regions), Invest Terms and help centre, verified August 2026. Both brokers’ terms are subject to change — verify before opening an account.
The FX fee gap is the real differentiator
Both brokers charge no commission on ETF trades within their own rules, so a EUR investor buying EUR-priced UCITS ETFs from a EUR account pays nothing at either. The gap opens the moment a trade crosses currencies — for example an S&P 500 UCITS ETF quoted in USD, or a UK-listed ETF quoted in GBP.
XTB adds 0.5% to its exchange rate on every stock or ETF trade that needs a conversion. Where it quotes no direct pair between the two currencies, it converts via USD and charges 0.5% at each step. Manual transfers between your own XTB cash accounts in different currencies cost 0.5%, rising to 0.8% at weekends and on holidays when currencies are not quoted. Trading 212 charges 0.15% on the live interbank rate and states the fee is never more than 0.15%, including at weekends. Dividends are not charged Trading 212’s FX fee.
What one cross-currency purchase costs
| Trade size | XTB (0.5%) | Trading 212 (0.15%) | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| €1,000 | €5.00 | €1.50 | €3.50 |
| €5,000 | €25.00 | €7.50 | €17.50 |
| €10,000 | €50.00 | €15.00 | €35.00 |
| €50,000 | €250.00 | €75.00 | €175.00 |
Our calculation: each broker’s stated FX fee applied to the full trade value, one direction, single-step conversion. Source: XTB S.A. and XTB UK fee tables, verified September 2026; Trading 212 Terms & Fees, verified August 2026.
Investing €1,000 a month in a USD-priced ETF costs €60 a year in conversion fees at XTB against €18 at Trading 212 — a €42 gap, or €420 over ten years of unchanged contributions. Selling converts back, so a full round trip costs 1.0% at XTB and 0.30% at Trading 212.
Both brokers let you sidestep conversion by holding the instrument’s currency. XTB offers GBP, EUR and USD accounts in the UK and EUR and USD deposits in Germany. Trading 212’s Multi-Currency account holds 12 currencies, and choosing the instrument currency on an order avoids the FX fee. One exception matters for automated investors: Trading 212 does not support multiple currencies inside Pies. Every Pie order is placed in your account’s primary currency, so a USD-priced holding in a EUR Pie is converted at 0.15% on every AutoInvest run.
XTB’s €100,000 monthly threshold — who it actually affects
XTB’s zero commission on stocks and ETFs applies up to €100,000 of cumulative turnover per calendar month, across all your registered accounts. Buys and sells both count, Investment Plan purchases count, and the threshold resets each month. Any trade after it is exceeded costs 0.2%, with a minimum of €10. Trading 212’s price list shows €0 commission with no turnover threshold.
XTB’s own worked example shows how the minimum bites: four trades totalling €95,000, then a fifth of €7,500. Only €2,500 sits above the threshold, and 0.2% of that is €5 — below the floor, so €10 is charged. At the other end, a €150,000 rebalance in a single month is charged 0.2% on the €50,000 above the threshold: €100 that Trading 212 does not charge. For a monthly saver investing a few hundred or a few thousand euros, the cap never comes into play.
XTB’s inactivity fee — narrower than it looks
XTB’s UK, Polish and Cyprus fee tables charge €10 a month (£10 per XTB UK’s site) only when both conditions hold: no position opened or closed in the last 365 days, and no deposit in the last 90 days. A single trade or deposit resets it.
Three carve-outs narrow it further. The fee is not charged while you hold an open position on any account, so a buy-and-hold investor sitting on ETFs is never caught. Where free funds are insufficient, the fee equals what remains, so it stops at a zero balance. And XTB’s German branch schedule charges no inactivity fee at all; neither does the French PEA, and XTB UK’s ISA accounts are exempt. The account it can reach is one that has sold everything and left cash sitting idle.
Trading 212’s price list has no inactivity fee row in any region. Its UK and EU terms do contain a dormancy rule: an account with a zero balance and no transactions for six consecutive months can be terminated without prior notice, and after 12 months without a login Trading 212 may require identity re-verification and restrict the account to selling only until that is done.
Investment Plans vs Pies and AutoInvest
Both brokers automate monthly investing. Trading 212’s tooling is more configurable; XTB’s plans are simpler, with up to 20 holdings per plan against 50 per Pie, and cost nothing to run.
XTB — Investment Plans
- Free to set up and run
- Up to 10 plans, each holding up to 20 instruments at 5%–100% weight
- ETFs and stocks: ready-made, sector and DIY plans
- Minimum €15, £15 or $15 per plan
- Auto-invest: you choose the amount, the period and the deposit method
- Created in the mobile app or on the web platform
- Purchases count toward the €100,000 monthly commission threshold
- Germany: recurring top-ups by PayU card cost 0.70% on EUR (from 30.09.2026)
Trading 212 — Pies and AutoInvest
- Pies of up to 50 holdings, minimum slice weight 0.1%
- Pie schedules: daily, weekly, every two weeks, monthly, every two months, every six months
- Single-instrument AutoInvest with no Pie, shown as a Savings Plan (Sparplan) under Trading 212 EU
- Minimum €1 per slice: the smallest slice must reach €1
- Dividend reinvestment on by default, into the same share
- Runs at 08:00 CET; Pie orders execute in regular market hours only
- Copy Pies and Model Pies set a starting allocation only
Two Pie details are commonly overstated. Neither distribution mode sells anything: Self-Balancing, the default, sends new money to underweight slices first, while By Targets splits it exactly by target weight even if a slice is already overweight. Pulling a drifted Pie back to target is a separate, manual rebalance. And dividend reinvestment only triggers once the dividend clears a threshold set by the minimum order and the smallest slice weight; below it, dividends collect as Pie cash.
The minimum scales with your smallest slice: a Pie whose smallest slice is 4% needs a €25 contribution for that slice to reach €1. Trading 212’s scheduling figures sit in its help centre rather than in its terms, so they can change without a terms update.
XTB’s Investment Plans are not available inside XTB UK’s ISA. XTB’s platform, xStation, runs on mobile, desktop and tablet, with an economic calendar and education courses; XTB finished Best in Class (a top-seven finish) for Overall, Ease of Use and Beginners in the ForexBrokers.com 2026 Annual Awards, and offers a demo account. Trading 212 offers a Practice Mode inside a registered account with a USD 50,000 virtual balance.
What you can hold — and which entity decides it
Which products you get depends on the legal entity that serves your country, not on the brand. This matters most for Dutch readers: XTB serves Netherlands residents through XTB Limited (Cyprus), which offers stock and ETF CFDs but no real stocks or ETFs. Trading 212 serves the Netherlands through Trading 212 EU GmbH, with real stocks and ETFs.
XTB
- Real stocks and ETFs through XTB S.A. and XTB UK (not the Cyprus entity)
- Fractional Rights, priced like whole shares
- Investment Plans
- CFDs on indices, commodities, currencies, stocks and ETFs
- Options at XTB UK, XTB Cyprus and XTB S.A.’s German branch
- PEA for French tax residents; Stocks and Shares ISA and Cash ISA in the UK
Trading 212
- Invest account: shares, fractional shares and ETFs
- CFD account
- Crypto for EU clients, provided by Trading 212 Markets Ltd rather than Trading 212 EU
- UK only: Stocks ISA, Cash ISA and SIPP
- Multi-Currency account in 12 currencies (Invest only)
- Not offered to residents of Belgium, the United States or Canada
Neither broker gives a reliable universe count. Trading 212 publishes none, and XTB’s own pages disagree with each other; XTB’s UK Investment Plans page lists 1,800+ ETFs and 3,400+ stocks (read September 2026). For a one-fund or two-fund UCITS ETF portfolio, availability of the major iShares, Vanguard and Amundi lines is what matters — check your specific ISIN on each platform before opening an account.
Interest on uninvested cash depends on your entity
Neither broker pays one rate to everyone, so a single “XTB pays X, Trading 212 pays Y” comparison is wrong for most readers.
XTB — rates as published, read 23 September 2026
XTB UK: GBP up to 4.00%, EUR 2.30%, USD 3.45% AER, variable. XTB Germany: a preferential EUR 3.50% and USD 3.40% for the first 90 days after account opening, on the first €100,000 across all accounts; the standard rate after 90 days and on balances above €100,000 is published on XTB’s German interest page. Other countries: check the interest page on XTB’s site for your country.
Rates can change weekly. Interest accrues daily and is paid within five working days of month end, with no minimum balance. XTB states it is not a bank. Under XTB UK’s terms, cash held inside an Investment Plan earns no interest.
Trading 212 pays interest daily with no minimum or maximum balance — but only if you opt in. Without the opt-in, uninvested cash stays in bank accounts, no interest is paid to you, and Trading 212 keeps all the interest it receives. With it, cash may be placed in qualifying money market funds, which are client assets rather than deposits and are not covered by deposit guarantee schemes. Trading 212 is not a bank.
Trading 212’s EUR rate differs between its UK, EU and Cyprus entities, and each quotes it in a different convention: AER in the UK, p.a. under Trading 212 EU, APY under Trading 212 Markets. Trading 212 EU states that the rates on its Terms & Fees page apply to new clients, and that existing clients see their own rate in the app’s Interest tab. CAD and CHF pay no interest.
For German clients, XTB states that cash on the clearing account is held on trust omnibus accounts at partner banks, currently including J.P. Morgan SE, and is protected by the German deposit guarantee scheme up to €100,000 if a bank fails. XTB does not state the equivalent for other countries.
What each broker states about support
XTB states that customer service runs 24 hours a day, five days a week, and that clients can reach it by email, chat or phone Monday to Friday in 18 languages. In Germany, German-language support runs Monday to Friday from 09:00 to 18:00, with English support 24/5 outside those hours.
Trading 212’s terms and price list do not state support hours or languages. Its EU entity sets out a formal complaints route: first contact at info@trading212.com, escalation to an independent compliance department at complaints.de@trading212.com, acknowledgement with a reference within three days, and a target outcome within three weeks. Unresolved complaints can go to the arbitration board at BaFin.
Regulation, custody and investor compensation
XTB
- XTB S.A.: investment firm authorised by the KNF in Poland; listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange since 2016, reporting earnings and cash reserves quarterly
- Branches: Germany (registered with BaFin, supervised by the KNF), France (AMF and ACPR), Spain (CNMV no. 40), Portugal (CMVM no. 341)
- XTB Limited (UK): FCA. XTB Limited (Cyprus): CySEC licence 169/12
- Compensation, XTB S.A.: KDPW scheme, 100% up to €3,000 and 90% above, maximum €20,100 per investor; Fractional Rights not covered
- Compensation, Cyprus entity: ICF, up to €20,000. UK: FSCS £85,000 on investments, under XTB’s terms
- Holdings on an omnibus account with a partner custodian; client money segregated from XTB’s own funds
Trading 212
- Trading 212 EU GmbH (BaFin): Germany, Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Iceland, Ireland, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland
- Trading 212 Markets Ltd (CySEC 398/21): Italy, Poland, Portugal, Greece and 12 other EU states
- Trading 212 UK Ltd: FCA
- EU equity orders are executed by Trading 212 Markets (Ireland) Ltd, authorised by the Central Bank of Ireland
- Custodians: Interactive Brokers and BNY Mellon (UK, EU entities); Interactive Brokers only (Cyprus entity)
- Compensation, EU entity: EdW, 90% of value capped at €20,000; plus deposit protection up to €100,000 per partner bank. Cyprus entity: ICF up to €20,000. UK: FSCS £85,000 total for cash and investments combined
One structural point for German and Dutch readers: Trading 212 EU holds securities in omnibus accounts at external sub-custodians, and your claim is a contractual right to delivery of the securities — not co-ownership at a German central securities depository, which is the standard model at German bank brokers. Trading 212 states this itself in its Invest Terms and disclosure document. In a custodian shortfall, clients share pro rata.
CFD trading carries high risk. The majority of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs. These products are complex instruments and may not be suitable for all investors. Verify compensation scheme coverage with your specific entity before depositing.
XTB’s two KNF fines
2018: the Polish regulator KNF fined X-Trade Brokers DM SA, now XTB SA, PLN 9,900,000 for breaching best-interest rules. Between January 2014 and May 2015, XTB applied an asymmetric parameter in instant execution — filling orders when the price moved in its favour and rejecting them when it moved in the client’s favour — and applied a delay parameter to a selected group of clients. The Voivodeship Administrative Court in Warsaw dismissed XTB’s complaint, and the Supreme Administrative Court dismissed its cassation appeal on 28 February 2023.
2026: by a decision of 30 March 2026, published on 13 April 2026, the KNF fined XTB SA PLN 20,000,000 for four breaches between 2022 and 2023: inadequate assessment of clients’ knowledge and experience before offering CFDs, a target market not defined appropriately, unidentified conflicts of interest around its “HOT list” — which the KNF notes promoted instruments with higher spreads — and unreliable and misleading information on CFD risks.
Pros and cons
XTB
Pros
- No commission up to €100,000 of monthly turnover
- Free Investment Plans holding ETFs and stocks
- Listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange, reporting quarterly
- German branch: no inactivity fee, €1 minimums
- PEA for French tax residents
Cons
- 0.5% FX fee — more than 3x Trading 212’s, and charged twice when converted via USD
- €10 monthly inactivity fee (£10 per XTB UK’s site) outside Germany once both conditions are met
- 0.02% p.a. custody on portfolio value above €250,000
- Dutch residents get CFDs only, no real ETFs
- Two KNF fines: PLN 9.9m (2018) and PLN 20m (2026)
Trading 212
Pros
- 0.15% FX fee, including weekends; no FX fee on dividends
- No commission and no custody fee, with no turnover threshold
- Pies of up to 50 holdings plus single-instrument AutoInvest
- Interest paid daily on opted-in cash
- No Trading 212 fee on portfolio transfers
Cons
- No multi-currency inside Pies, so foreign holdings convert on every run
- Interest rates differ by entity; Trading 212 EU’s published rates are for new clients
- EU clients hold a contractual right to delivery, not CSD co-ownership
- Fractional shares cannot be transferred out and are liquidated instead
- Not available to residents of Belgium
The decision framework
For a passive investor building a UCITS ETF portfolio, the tiebreaker is currency. If you ever buy ETFs or stocks priced in a currency your account doesn’t hold — USD-priced ETF lines, US stocks, GBP-priced UK listings — Trading 212 is cheaper on every such trade: 0.15% against 0.5%, or 0.30% against 1.0% on a full round trip. Its Pies and single-instrument AutoInvest are also the more configurable automation, though a Pie cannot avoid the FX fee on foreign holdings.
XTB is the stronger fit in three situations: you only ever buy EUR-priced ETFs from a EUR account, so the FX fee never applies; you are in France and want a PEA; or you want CFDs, where XTB is a CFD-led broker — its own results show CFDs generate the overwhelming majority of its trading revenue. German residents also avoid the inactivity fee entirely under XTB’s German branch schedule.
For Dutch residents the choice is made for you: XTB serves the Netherlands through its Cyprus entity, which offers CFDs only. If you want real ETFs, Trading 212 is the one of these two that offers them in the Netherlands.
Check the current terms before you open an account
Fees, rates and country availability change. Confirm the figures on each broker’s own pricing pages, and check which entity covers your country of residence, before opening or funding an account. XTB figures verified September 2026; Trading 212 figures verified August 2026. CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly.
Go deeper
Common questions
Is XTB better than Trading 212 for ETF investing?
For ETFs priced in a currency other than your account currency, Trading 212 is cheaper: its FX fee is 0.15% against XTB’s 0.5%. Both charge no commission on ETF trades, XTB up to EUR 100,000 of monthly turnover and 0.2% (minimum EUR 10) above it. If you buy EUR-priced ETFs from a EUR account, no conversion applies at either broker. Dutch residents are served by XTB’s Cyprus entity, which offers CFDs only, not real ETFs.
What is the FX fee difference between XTB and Trading 212?
XTB charges 0.5% on trades that need a currency conversion, and where no direct currency pair is quoted it converts via USD and charges 0.5% at each step. Trading 212 charges 0.15%, including at weekends. On a EUR 10,000 cross-currency purchase that is EUR 50 at XTB against EUR 15 at Trading 212. Investing EUR 1,000 a month in a USD-priced ETF costs EUR 42 more per year in conversion fees at XTB.
Does XTB charge an inactivity fee?
Outside Germany, yes: EUR 10 a month (GBP 10 per XTB UK’s site) once no position has been opened or closed for 365 days and no deposit has been made for 90 days. It is not charged while you hold an open position on any account, and it stops at a zero balance. XTB’s German branch schedule charges no inactivity fee, and XTB UK’s ISA accounts are exempt. Trading 212’s price list has no inactivity fee row.
Which broker pays better interest on uninvested cash?
There is no single answer, because both brokers set rates per entity. XTB’s rate depends on the entity, and its German branch pays a preferential rate for the first 90 days. Trading 212 quotes rates in different conventions by entity (AER in the UK, p.a. under Trading 212 EU, APY under Trading 212 Markets), and Trading 212 EU states that its published rates apply to new clients. Trading 212 pays interest daily and only if you opt in; XTB accrues interest daily and pays it within five working days of month end.
Does XTB have phone support?
Yes. XTB states that customer service is available 24 hours a day, five days a week, and that clients can reach it by email, chat or phone Monday to Friday in 18 languages. In Germany, German-language support runs Monday to Friday from 09:00 to 18:00, with English support 24/5 outside those hours. Trading 212’s terms and price list do not state support hours or languages; complaints to Trading 212 EU go to info@trading212.com.
Which broker supports fractional shares?
Both. Trading 212’s minimum order is EUR 1 under its EU and Cyprus entities and GBP 1 in the UK. XTB’s minimum per stock or ETF is GBP 1 in the UK and EUR 1 in Germany and Portugal, while purchases in the French PEA start from EUR 10; XTB states no minimum for other countries. XTB’s fractional holdings are Fractional Rights, which XTB Poland says the KDPW compensation scheme does not cover.
Can I transfer my portfolio from XTB to Trading 212?
XTB charges EUR 25 per ISIN to transfer a holding out (0.10%, minimum EUR 100, for Spain-listed instruments). Under XTB’s UK Terms of Business, Fractional Rights cannot be transferred. Trading 212 charges no fee for portfolio transfers, accepts whole shares only in instruments tradeable on its platform, and does not offer portfolio transfers to Trading 212 EU clients residing in Germany. Selling and moving cash instead may trigger a taxable event depending on your country’s rules.
Get the free toolkit sample
A working broker cost calculator — IBKR vs DEGIRO vs Trading 212, with verified September 2026 fees. You’ll also get 4 short emails on cutting your investing costs. Unsubscribe anytime.
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.