Best Broker for German Investors (2026):
Sparplan, Vorabpauschale & PFOF ban
Germany’s broker market is changing fast — the EU PFOF ban hits in June 2026, interest rates have shifted, and a new generation of Wertpapierdepot options has emerged. The right pick still comes down to one question: do you want automated monthly ETF investing with German tax on autopilot, or manual control at the lowest possible cost? This guide covers five serious options — Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, Smartbroker+, IBKR, and DEGIRO — plus everything you need to know about German tax mechanics and what the PFOF ban means for your fees.
Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you sign up through them. This does not affect our reviews or recommendations — we only feature products we genuinely believe are useful for investors. This site provides educational content only, not personalized investment advice. Investments can lose value and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own financial decisions and for confirming the tax and legal rules that apply in your country.
Why opening a Wertpapierdepot matters in 2026
Germany has a well-earned reputation for financial caution — and for good reason to move past it.
According to Deutsche Rentenversicherung, Germany’s gross pension replacement rate (Rentenniveau) sits around 48% in 2026 and is projected to decline further. Fewer working-age contributors are supporting a growing retiree base. A Wertpapierdepot invested in broadly diversified UCITS ETFs is the most accessible long-term complement to the statutory pension — not a luxury, but a practical hedge against a known structural risk.
Germany’s household savings rate remains among Europe’s highest, yet a large share of that wealth still sits in Girokonten and Sparkonten. With inflation running above the effective return on standard savings accounts, doing nothing with your cash is not a neutral decision — it is a quiet, annual erosion of purchasing power. The Sparplan culture that has taken hold in Germany since 2020 exists precisely because more investors have understood this.
Three types of broker available to German investors
Germany’s broker landscape splits into three distinct categories. Understanding which type fits your situation is faster than reading every review in full.
Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, Smartbroker+. Built around Sparpläne and passive investing. Automatic Vorabpauschale and Freistellungsauftrag handling. The right starting point for most investors.
Suits: beginners, Sparplan investors, passive ETF buyers
ING DirectDepot, Comdirect, Consorsbank, DKB. Integrate your Girokonto, Tagesgeld, and Wertpapierdepot under one roof. Free Sparpläne on most ETFs. Automatic German tax handling. Higher per-trade costs than neobrokers.
Suits: investors who want one bank for everything; couples (Gemeinschaftsdepot); families (Junior Depot)
IBKR, DEGIRO. Multi-currency accounts, global markets, options, and bonds. No automatic Vorabpauschale — you declare it in your Steuererklärung. Best for advanced investors or those investing larger sums.
Suits: advanced traders, multi-currency investors, expats who may relocate
Best brokers for German investors at a glance
| Broker | Type | ETF Sparplan | Vorabpauschale | English support | Deposit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trade Republic | Neobroker | ✅ Free, from €1/mo | ✅ Automatic | ✅ Full | Transfer, card, Apple/Google Pay |
| Scalable Capital | Neobroker | ✅ Free (PRIME+) | ✅ Automatic | ✅ Full | Bank transfer only |
| Smartbroker+ | Neobroker | ✅ Free | ✅ Automatic | ⚠️ Primarily German | Bank transfer only |
| IBKR | International | ❌ Not available | ⚠️ Manual | ✅ Full | Bank transfer only |
| DEGIRO | International | ❌ Not available | ⚠️ Manual | ✅ Full | Bank transfer only |
If you invest monthly via an automated ETF plan and want German tax handling on autopilot, Trade Republic is the default choice. Scalable Capital is the upgrade if you also make manual trades. Smartbroker+ is the Finanztip-recommended alternative if you want free trades without a subscription.
IBKR wins for multi-currency accounts, global market access, options, and bonds. DEGIRO is the alternative if you want a German-bank-backed entity and low per-trade fees — both require manual Vorabpauschale handling.
The three tax rules that shape every broker decision in Germany
Germany’s investing tax system is more involved than most European countries. These three mechanics determine which broker makes sense for you — and are the main reason neobrokers have a real edge over international platforms for most German retail investors.
Each January, German law applies a prepayment tax on the notional return of accumulating ETFs — even if you sold nothing. The formula: Basiszins × Fondswert × 0.7. Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, and Smartbroker+ withhold it automatically and debit your cash balance. With IBKR or DEGIRO you declare it in your annual Steuererklärung — or via a Steuerberater.
Your Sparerpauschbetrag — the annual saver’s allowance — is €1,000 per person (€2,000 for jointly assessed couples) in capital gains and investment income exempt from Kapitalertragsteuer. Submit a Freistellungsauftrag to your broker digitally — all three neobrokers do this in-app. You can split it across brokers, but the total must stay within €1,000.
Capital gains above the Sparerpauschbetrag are taxed at 25% + Solidaritätszuschlag (≈26.375% effective). For equity ETFs, the Teilfreistellung reduces the taxable base by 30% — improving after-tax returns significantly. German-registered brokers apply Teilfreistellung automatically on qualifying UCITS funds.
Germany’s Sparplan edge — and why it shapes broker choice
Germany invests more of its ETF flows through automated Sparpläne than almost any other European market. According to the Deutsches Aktieninstitut, around 21 million people in Germany held fund or ETF savings plans in 2024 — and that figure has grown every year. Broker competition has followed, pushing Sparplan costs to near-zero.
- Automates DCA — removes market-timing decisions entirely.
- Forces consistent investing regardless of sentiment.
- From €1/month — accessible at any income level.
- Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, and Smartbroker+ all execute them free or near-free.
- Vorabpauschale is handled automatically alongside — no February admin.
- Neither broker supports automated monthly ETF Sparpläne natively.
- You must log in and place orders manually each month.
- Fine for larger lump sums — impractical for small regular contributions.
- This is the most overlooked disadvantage in most international broker comparisons of German options.
The EU PFOF ban: what it means for your broker fees
This is the biggest structural shift in Germany’s retail broker market since neobrokers launched. It affects every platform on this list — and you need to understand it before choosing where to open a Depot.
Payment for Order Flow (PFOF) is the revenue model behind many “commission-free” platforms. Brokers receive payments from market makers (like Lang & Schwarz) in exchange for routing customer orders to them — rather than finding the best available price in the open market. The market maker profits from the spread; the broker earns a rebate; the investor gets “free” trading — but often at a slightly worse execution price than they might get elsewhere. The EU decided this conflict of interest is incompatible with best execution obligations under MiFID II.
Already adapted. Trade Republic charges €1 per manual trade — the PFOF rebate was already partly replaced by a visible transaction fee. Sparplan executions remain €0. The transition is cleaner here than at most peers.
Subscription model insulates it. Scalable PRIME+ (€4.99/month) is not dependent on PFOF revenue — it’s a flat-fee model. The free tier (€0.99/trade) may see pricing adjustments, but PRIME+ holders are well-positioned post-ban.
Routes via Gettex. Orders ≥€500 execute on Gettex without PFOF dependency — the cost structure is exchange-based rather than market-maker-rebate-based. A more transparent model for post-ban compliance.
Trade Republic — best overall for most German investors
Trade Republic launched in Germany in 2019 and is now one of Europe’s largest retail brokers by user count. BaFin-regulated. Customer deposits held at Deutsche Bank, Citibank, and HSBC. The entire platform is built around automated, low-cost ETF investing with German tax handling included.
- Free Sparpläne on thousands of UCITS ETFs — from €1/month, any schedule.
- Vorabpauschale auto-handled — debited from your cash balance each January, nothing to declare manually.
- Freistellungsauftrag in-app — set in under a minute, applied automatically.
- Interest on uninvested cash — ECB-linked, competitive variable rate. Verify current rate on Trade Republic’s website before opening.
- €1 flat fee per manual trade — negligible for long-term investors making few transactions.
- German IBAN, Visa debit card, Apple/Google Pay funding — the most flexible deposit options of any broker on this list.
- Full English-language app and support — one of the best for expats in Germany.
- PFOF ban: already adapted with €1/trade model. Sparplan executions remain free.
- Mobile-first — no full desktop trading platform.
- Limited order types: no conditional orders, trailing stops, or limit order depth.
- No options, futures, bonds, or margin trading.
- Single trading venue (Lang & Schwarz) — less price discovery than multi-venue brokers.
- No Gemeinschaftsdepot (joint account) — relevant for couples who want shared investing.
- App design rewards engagement — requires discipline to stay passive.
Scalable Capital — best for flat-fee active investors
Founded in Munich in 2014, Scalable Capital started as a robo-advisor and evolved into a full brokerage. Its PRIME+ plan at €4.99/month covers unlimited trades and Sparpläne — the natural step up from Trade Republic for investors who also make manual transactions.
- PRIME+ subscription: €4.99/month covers unlimited ETF trades and savings plans on Gettex and Xetra.
- 2,000+ UCITS ETFs including niche, thematic, and factor products not available at Trade Republic.
- Vorabpauschale & Freistellungsauftrag handled automatically — same quality as Trade Republic.
- Desktop platform with portfolio analytics and charting — more capable than Trade Republic’s web view.
- Two trading venues (Gettex and Xetra) — better price discovery than single-venue peers.
- Competitive interest on uninvested cash — ECB-linked variable rate. Verify current rate on Scalable’s website.
- PFOF ban: subscription model is structurally independent of PFOF revenue.
- Full English-language app and support — good for expats.
- Monthly subscription cost — if you only run a Sparplan, Trade Republic or Smartbroker+ is cheaper.
- Free tier charges €0.99/trade — works out worse than Smartbroker+ for infrequent traders above the Gettex threshold.
- Customer support historically slower than traditional brokers.
- No multi-currency accounts or deep global market access at IBKR’s level.
- No options or futures trading.
- No Gemeinschaftsdepot (joint account).
Smartbroker+ — best for no-subscription free trading
Smartbroker+ is a specifically German product — backed by Baader Bank, BaFin-regulated, and recommended by Finanztip, Germany’s largest independent financial advice platform. It fills the gap between Trade Republic’s limited order infrastructure and Scalable’s subscription requirement.
- Free ETF Sparpläne — no execution fee, no minimum subscription required.
- Commission-free trades on Gettex for orders ≥€500 — no monthly fee needed to access zero-cost trading.
- Vorabpauschale auto-handled via Baader Bank — same standard as Trade Republic and Scalable.
- Finanztip recommendation — Germany’s most trusted independent financial advice site lists Smartbroker+ as a top depot pick.
- Backed by Baader Bank — well-established German banking infrastructure.
- Broader order type support than Trade Republic.
- PFOF ban: Gettex routing for qualifying orders is exchange-based, not PFOF-dependent.
- Primarily German-language — app and support are not consistently available in English. Not the ideal pick for expats who need full English access.
- Free trades only apply on Gettex for orders ≥€500. Smaller orders or other venues incur standard fees.
- Less polished mobile app experience compared to Trade Republic and Scalable Capital.
- No Gemeinschaftsdepot (joint account).
- Narrower product universe than IBKR.
QuantRoutine does not have an affiliate relationship with Smartbroker+. This is an informational link only.
Interactive Brokers — best for multi-currency and advanced investors
IBKR is the professional-grade option for German investors who have outgrown the neobroker world. It offers access to stocks, ETFs, options, bonds, and forex across 150+ markets from one account. The trade-off is that it does not fit German retail investor tax workflows out of the box.
- Multi-currency account: hold EUR, USD, GBP, and more simultaneously. FX via IBKR’s Smart Routing is among the cheapest available to retail investors (~0.002% markup).
- Lowest fees at scale: IBKR’s tiered pricing beats all German neobrokers for large international trades.
- Global market access: options, futures, bonds, global stocks across 150 markets — no other broker on this list is close.
- Annual consolidated tax statement to assist with German filing.
- Interest paid on cash balances above threshold — ECB-rate-linked, competitive for larger portfolios.
- No minimum deposit, no inactivity fees.
- Full English platform and support — excellent for expats who may relocate and want a portable, globally recognised broker.
- PFOF ban: IBKR’s pricing model is not PFOF-dependent. No expected impact.
- No Vorabpauschale automation: you must calculate and declare the annual prepayment tax yourself. This is the single most significant practical burden for German investors using IBKR.
- No Sparplan support: no automated monthly savings plans.
- Steep learning curve — TWS (Trader Workstation) is powerful but not beginner-friendly.
- Not built around German investor workflows: no Freistellungsauftrag in-platform (claim in Steuererklärung instead).
- No Gemeinschaftsdepot.
DEGIRO — low-cost trades, German banking backbone
DEGIRO is backed by flatexDEGIRO Bank AG — a fully BaFin-regulated German bank — which makes it the most domestically anchored international-style broker on this list. Strong on per-trade costs and exchange breadth. Weak on the features that matter most to typical German passive investors.
- flatexDEGIRO Bank AG: BaFin-regulated German bank entity — full €100,000 deposit insurance.
- Low per-trade costs: €3 total (€2 commission + €1 handling) on most European exchanges.
- Core Selection ETFs: a rotating list of ETFs that trade effectively commission-free (€1 handling only) once per month.
- Wide ETF and stock universe across Euronext, Xetra, LSE, and US markets.
- Full English-language platform — good for expats comfortable filing taxes manually.
- PFOF ban: DEGIRO’s fee structure is exchange-based. No significant impact expected.
- No ETF Sparpläne: cannot automate regular monthly investments — rules it out for the majority of German passive investors.
- Vorabpauschale not auto-handled: manual declaration required in your Steuererklärung.
- No interest paid on uninvested cash.
- Basic account vs. Custody account distinction — impacts how assets are held and securities lending exposure. Understand this before opening.
- No Gemeinschaftsdepot.
- FX markup of 0.25% (AutoFX) applies to all foreign-currency trades — adds up on international ETF purchases.
Opening a Wertpapierdepot as an expat in Germany
For expats, the broker decision involves factors that don’t appear in standard fee comparisons: English-language support, non-EU national eligibility, portability if you leave Germany, and access to account types that matter for families.
- Trade Republic: full English app, website, and customer support. One of the best expat experiences.
- Scalable Capital: full English app and support. Excellent for expats.
- IBKR: full English platform and global support team. Best option for international investors who may relocate.
- DEGIRO: English platform available. Customer support can be slower.
- Smartbroker+: primarily German-language. Not recommended if English support is a priority.
- Eligibility: most brokers require a German address and German bank IBAN. Verify before applying if you’re a non-EU national.
- Portability: IBKR is the most portable — it serves investors across most countries, so you won’t need to close your account if you relocate. Neobrokers may require account closure if you leave Germany.
- Gemeinschaftsdepot (joint account): Trade Republic, Scalable, and Smartbroker+ do not offer joint accounts. ING DirectDepot and Comdirect do — relevant for couples who want a shared Depot.
- Junior Depot: for families investing for children — generally offered by direct banks (ING, Comdirect), not neobrokers.
- Tax declaration for non-German-registered brokers: if using IBKR or DEGIRO, you file capital gains and Vorabpauschale in your annual Steuererklärung. Budget for this or use a Steuerberater.
Which broker is right for you?
- You invest via a monthly ETF Sparplan and rarely place manual orders
- You want Vorabpauschale handled entirely automatically
- You’re a beginner or expat who needs full English support
- You want to earn competitive interest on uninvested cash
- You want Apple Pay / Google Pay funding convenience
- You make more than ~5 manual trades per month alongside your Sparplan
- You need access to a broader ETF universe than Trade Republic offers
- You want a desktop platform for portfolio analysis and charting
- You want one account for both automation and occasional active control
- You’re comfortable in German and want free trades without a subscription fee
- Your typical order size is €500 or above (Gettex free-trade threshold)
- You follow Finanztip’s recommendations and want their top-pick depot
- You want free Sparpläne plus no monthly platform cost
- You need a multi-currency account (EUR + USD + GBP simultaneously)
- You trade options, bonds, or futures
- You invest large lump sums and want the lowest possible per-trade cost
- You’re an expat who may relocate and needs a portable global broker
- You’re comfortable managing Vorabpauschale in your Steuererklärung
- You invest manually in larger lump sums and don’t need a Sparplan
- You want the security of a BaFin-regulated German bank entity (flatexDEGIRO Bank AG)
- You use the Core Selection ETF list to minimise per-trade costs
- You have a Steuerberater who handles Vorabpauschale for you
- You want your Girokonto, Tagesgeld, and Wertpapierdepot all in one place
- You need a Gemeinschaftsdepot (joint account with your partner)
- You want a Junior Depot to invest for your children
- You prefer the stability of an established German banking institution over a neobroker
- Best picks: ING DirectDepot for ETF Sparpläne; Comdirect for full banking integration
Ready to open your Wertpapierdepot?
For most German investors: Trade Republic for Sparpläne with autopilot tax handling, Scalable Capital if you also trade actively, IBKR if you need multi-currency scale or global portability.
Go deeper
Frequently asked questions
Which broker is best for ETF savings plans (Sparpläne) in Germany?
Trade Republic and Scalable Capital are the top neobroker picks. Trade Republic offers free Sparpläne on thousands of UCITS ETFs from €1/month with automatic Vorabpauschale handling and full English support. Scalable Capital’s PRIME+ plan (€4.99/month) adds a broader ETF universe and a desktop platform. Smartbroker+ (backed by Baader Bank) is the Finanztip-recommended alternative if you want free Sparpläne without a monthly subscription — primarily for German-speaking investors. All three handle Vorabpauschale automatically, which is the key advantage over IBKR and DEGIRO.
How does Vorabpauschale work and which brokers handle it automatically?
Vorabpauschale is an annual prepayment tax on the notional return of accumulating ETFs, applied each January — even if you sold nothing. The calculation uses the German Basiszins, your fund’s value at the start of the year, and a factor of 0.7. Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, and Smartbroker+ calculate and withhold it automatically, applying your Freistellungsauftrag first and debiting any remaining amount from your cash balance. With IBKR or DEGIRO, you must calculate it yourself and declare it in your annual Steuererklärung — or use a Steuerberater.
What is Smartbroker+ and is it worth it for German investors?
Smartbroker+ is a BaFin-regulated German broker backed by Baader Bank. It offers free ETF Sparpläne with automatic Vorabpauschale handling, plus commission-free ETF and stock trades on Gettex for orders of €500 or more — all without a monthly subscription fee. It is recommended by Finanztip, Germany’s most trusted independent financial advice platform, and is a strong option for cost-conscious German-speaking investors. The main limitation: it operates primarily in German, so it’s less suitable for expats who need English-language support.
How will the EU PFOF ban affect brokers in Germany?
Payment for Order Flow (PFOF) is the model behind many “commission-free” platforms — brokers receive rebates from market makers in exchange for routing orders to them. The EU is banning this practice under MiFIR, with German brokers required to comply by 30 June 2026. For investors, this means the era of purely zero-cost trading is ending. Trade Republic has already adapted with its €1/trade model while keeping Sparpläne free. Scalable Capital’s subscription model is structurally independent of PFOF. Smartbroker+ routes via Gettex on an exchange-cost basis. IBKR and DEGIRO are not affected as they don’t rely on PFOF revenue.
Which brokers support English for expats in Germany?
Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, IBKR, and DEGIRO all offer full English-language apps, websites, and customer support — making them the natural choices for expats. Smartbroker+ and flatex operate primarily in German. For expats who may eventually relocate, IBKR is the strongest long-term option due to its global reach and account portability — you can keep the same account across most countries without closing your Depot.
Is DEGIRO available in Germany?
Yes. DEGIRO’s parent company is flatexDEGIRO Bank AG, a fully BaFin-regulated German bank, providing deposit insurance up to €100,000. This is DEGIRO’s strongest selling point in Germany. The main drawback for most passive investors: no ETF Sparpläne and no automatic Vorabpauschale handling. Also note the difference between DEGIRO’s Basic and Custody account types — they have different asset protection structures and it’s worth understanding this before opening. Full guide: DEGIRO Basic vs Custody.
Can I use Interactive Brokers as a German resident?
Yes. IBKR is fully available to German residents and is a popular choice for investors who need multi-currency accounts, options, margin, or global market access. The practical challenges: no Sparplan support, and Vorabpauschale is not handled automatically — you must declare it in your annual Steuererklärung. IBKR does provide an annual consolidated tax statement to help. For passive ETF investors running a monthly Sparplan, Trade Republic or Scalable Capital are more practical — but IBKR is the better long-term infrastructure for investors who move countries or trade complex instruments.
What is the Freistellungsauftrag and how do I set it up?
The Freistellungsauftrag is a tax exemption order that applies your Sparerpauschbetrag — the €1,000 annual saver’s allowance (€2,000 for jointly assessed couples) — before any Kapitalertragsteuer or Abgeltungsteuer is withheld on your investment gains. You submit it digitally to your broker — Trade Republic, Scalable Capital, and Smartbroker+ all have this in-app and it takes under a minute. You can split the allowance across multiple brokers, but the combined total across all brokers must not exceed €1,000 per person. With international brokers like IBKR or DEGIRO, you typically claim the allowance in your annual Steuererklärung rather than setting it on the platform.
QuantRoutine provides educational content only. Nothing on this page is an offer, solicitation, or recommendation to buy or sell any security or to open an account with any specific broker. Investments can lose value, and past performance does not guarantee future results. You are responsible for your own investment, tax, and legal decisions. Always review each broker’s current terms, fees, and eligibility on their official website before opening or funding an account. Tax rules referenced (Vorabpauschale, Freistellungsauftrag, Abgeltungsteuer) are provided for educational context only — consult a qualified Steuerberater for advice specific to your situation.